Previously, we discussed the working principles, installation, and adjustments of bass dynamometers on a general level. Now, we will delve deeper into the differences between the different models. We tested six different models that represent both the full-range and midrange heads.
The bass vibration market is quite narrow. The most well-known brands are Aurasound, Dayton Audio and Monacor. There are also some products from Järemi called Buttkicker. And the prices are indeed quite affordable, ranging from 15 to 100 euros, with the most expensive ones costing as much as 400-600 euros.
In Finland, the availability of products seems to be somewhat limited. However, Hifikulma (Dayton Audio importer) and Discoland sell bass speakers. The largest selection from foreign (reliable) online stores seems to be on Soundimports.eu. We also ordered these six different types of bass speakers for testing from there. From the little Dayton Audios for only 17 euros to the hefty Buttkicker costing 530 euros.
Vibrators were tested both when mounted on a gaming chair and in a reclining chair during movie screenings.
The test benches included a high-back, armless office chair simulating a gaming chair, and a medium-weight wooden chair for home theater use. A separate metal plate was attached to the base of the gaming chair, which connected to both the seat and the backrest. The shock absorber was attached to this plate at the bottom. In the armchair, the shock absorber was attached in a horizontal position directly to the back of the chair’s frame. In principle, however, the most effective orientation would be upright.
The amplifiers were the Nobsound NS-01G PRO ordered from Soundimport and the more powerful Fosi Audio M03 mono-subwoofer amplifier.
From smaller to larger
The test included a wide variety of bass transducers from small and inexpensive pucks to heavy-duty infrasound transducers. The differences were not limited to power or the ability to move mass, but also to how controlled and balanced the vibration behaves at different frequencies.
ButtKicker BK-LFE was clearly the most powerful of the bunch. It moves even large masses effortlessly, reaching down to infrasonic frequencies, but it requires even more from home theaters: a sturdy structure and a large budget. Its playback is neat at low volumes, but for example a smooth shot feels like it doesn’t bring the kind of impact that a faster and more responsive vibrator would. This is at its best in high-end home theaters combined with smaller vibrators, allowing for both a deep and distinct effect.
The Dayton BST-300EX offered excellent performance for the price. It extends down to about 25 Hertz and can move even a larger sofa, several chairs, or a small table. Its distinct resonance requires equalization with a frequency corrector, but when properly adjusted, the BST-300EX combines power and separation beautifully.
The AuraSound AST-2B-4 and the Dayton BST-1 showed very well how much frequency correction and the right settings affect the final result. The performance of AuraSound was quite balanced but lacked power. The BST-1, on the other hand, was effective in size and price, but its 38–42 Hz resonance peak must be controlled with the EQ to prevent the playback from being too emphasized in one area. Both are best suited for multi-vibrator systems or with smaller seats.
The Monacor BR-50 was perhaps the “nicest” one in terms of its subdued performance, but at the same time it was noticeably quieter at lower frequencies. It doesn’t move the chair as much as others, but the vibration remains neat and controlled. This can be an advantage if you just want to reduce the physical impact. Maybe more for gaming than for movies.
Jatka artikkelin lukemista
Tämä artikkeli kuuluu AVPlus Extra -sisältöön. Jatka lukemista 2 krediitillä.






